My garden is sort of growing. I don't think the old paperwhite or amaryllis bulbs are going to come back, even though I followed the instructions for replanting. I might need to replant the chives. And that window isn't helping...(yes, some of that snow and ice is on the inside). But, all in all, it's a very satisfactory spot of green in a wintery world, which is what I'd hoped for last year when I got this new shelf.